I figured I would like Father Figure… And I was right!

father figureSome books start with a bang, others slowly build up in what seems like an orderly fashion- but don’t be fooled by the steady opening, such books can end with an avalanche of emotions and knock you off your feet. This was one such book. After Jay’s amazing debut last year, I was obviously excited to see what he came up with next. Now, this did initially take me some time to really get into, some parts clicking more than others, yet I very much appreciated the trickle of information, eroding any sense of stability I had, bit by bit.

The dual perspectives were done really well. There was plenty to latch onto with both stories and I found myself invested in both of the main characters- especially since both stories were so raw and emotional. Amalia was relatable and sympathetic; Brianna was incredibly likeable. I did get irritated with Brianna for not hearing Molly out- but I felt like this was a testament to how realistic the relationship was.

Speaking of things that were realistic, but I didn’t especially enjoy- if I had a friend like Shanelle, I wouldn’t need enemies. Me and bossy people do not mix- it’s the ultimate rock meets hard place- if someone tries to tell me what to do they’ll look like a cayote running into a brick wall. I can’t pretend that I liked anything about her: I hate nags, I can’t stand people that play games in relationships and woe betide anyone that tries to pressure someone into a relationship when they’re not ready. What can I say- I’m just not as agreeable as Briana and would have told her to eff off. Phew- glad I got that off my chest. THAT SAID, I did not see this as a criticism of the book, cos irritating or not, people like this exist and as I always say (sometimes 😉 ) eliciting a strong response means it’s more real. And I think it’s pretty clear from the way I’m talking about these folks that I felt they were very life-like.

Psychologically, I thought Cudney painted a striking picture of the bitter and resentful mother and the spiteful son. Both villains, for me, were spot on. I did unfortunately think that certain other additions were less believable- for instance I did not buy that about 90% of the men in the book were creepy pervs. There were just a few too many deeply unpleasant men and I needed more Jonah-type figures.

I loved the descriptive elements- more even than Watching Glass Shatter. The writing and imagery, as good as it was before, was vastly improved and struck a deeper chord. As the pace picked up, the drama became more harmonised and I was transported by the magnificent finale. I became more in tune to how the themes of the title wove into the narrative and saw how it was all interconnected from the start. The twists kept rolling and the story grew darker and things snapped into place. I don’t want to spoil anything- but believe me, it’s all about the ending with this one. Ultimately I got tingles from so many parts of the conclusion and felt just-stepped-off-a-rollercoaster giddy. It was that good.

Rating: 4/5 bananas


So have you read this? Do you plan to? Let me know in the comments!

24 thoughts on “I figured I would like Father Figure… And I was right!

  1. I am SO HAPPY that you loved it! I was blown away by Jay’s talent honestly. What you said about Shanelle being bossy is true and everything falling into place too. Seriously the plot twists and the scheming were amazin. I also agree with you about the descriptive elements. I wrote it in my review “I walked in the campus, I…”. Wonderful review 😉

    Liked by 2 people

  2. Wow, this sounds like an amazing book. I already have the writer’s first book on my to read list, so I will now be adding this one to the list as well. As always your reviews are way too convincing, and it’s hard to resist when someone writes such an enthusiastic review. Great post! 😊

    Liked by 1 person

  3. I had to avoid reading your review as I have yet to get to this one… Because I am a horrible person. Ha ha!! I’ve been so busy and trying to avoid having it spoiled for me, but I can’t wait to read it!! 💖💖💖🍻


  4. I am not even sure what to say right now! WOW! This is such an incredibly amazing review. You hit so many things that made me smile… from the improvement in the writing to the characterization of the villains… and how I wanted the ending to be. Thank you so much. I also wouldn’t have tolerated Shanelle — she’d have been out the door in the beginning. Yikes.

    I’m sharing this everywhere – it’s so amazing! 🙂

    Liked by 1 person

  5. Love your review!!! Jonah is such a darling… And Brian too. I wish there was more of them and less of some of the ucky ones… but it’s realistic that the world isn’t filled with just the sweet ones. I also enjoyed the raw and realistic characterisations. 🙂


  6. Great review! I love finding authors I enjoy, especially when I can follow them in their early writing career. This doesn’t sound like my type of genre so I won’t be picking it up, but I’m glad you enjoyed it!

    Liked by 1 person

  7. lol your comment about how unrealistic it is that 90% of the men in this book were creepy pervs…I feel exactly that way with IT (the movie, haven’t read the book). I really don’t like the trope of the entire cast being unreliable/untrustworthy characters, so I feel you on there. 😉 Also, I loved your rant on bossy people! I agree that characters like this exist IRL, but they can most definitely irk you while you’re reading about them. 😂 Terrific review!


  8. Really good review. The characters do certainly feel life-like. Other than being a bossy boots, Shanelle does sound really annoying lol. But I will say for the rest of us, bossy boots, sometimes, in my case, I need to be bossy otherwise things would just not get done.


  9. So nice to see James’ books continue to deliver on all fronts. What I seem to realize based on the reviews of others of his books is that he nails the way he develops his characters! Glad to see how much you enjoyed this. Awesome review! 😀

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s